As printed in Jewellery Business, August 2011 issue, p. 28-30
By Ronald R. Dupuis, FGA, GJ

Rolex 'Oyster Perpetual Datejust' in 18-karat yellow gold, with 'President' bracelet and lapis lazuli dial

Diamond and platinum pendant necklace set with synthetic sapphire, circa 1930.

The surprising reality of synthetic gemstones

If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, it probably is a duck, right? Maybe … or maybe not when it comes to gemstones.

Synthetic gemstones have the same chemical makeup as their naturally occurring counterparts. The difference is synthetics don’t originate randomly below ground through the geologic influences of nature. Instead, they are created under controlled conditions in a laboratory.

What they aren’t
Synthetic stones aren’t fake, faux, or costume, and shouldn’t be confused with brand-name inventions like moissanite, diamonelle, etc. They aren’t pastes, rhinestones, or marcasite, either. Despite the similarity in the name, cubic zirconia (CZ) – which has no equivalent counterpart in nature–has nothing to do with zircon. CZs are a look-alike for diamonds, but don’t have the same chemical makeup.

What they are
A dictionary definition of the term synthetic states that it refers to “compounds formed through a chemical process by human agency, as opposed to those of natural origin.” Synthetic gemstones have some major advantages over the real thing. Flaws and impurities present in nature can be diminished in scale and saturation of colour can be evenly distributed and matched.

The majority of us are comfortable using synthetic oil in our car engines, walking on easy-care synthetic carpeting, wearing wash-and-wear synthetic fabrics, or sitting on synthetic leather-look chairs while we swallow our synthetic vitamins. In these instances, there is no stigma attached. But use the term synthetic when selling jewellery, and the implications is it is a substandard material.

This wasn’t always the case. During the 1920s, jewellery designers at well-established houses with reputations for fine craftsmanship had no qualms using synthetic stones in their designs. These days, however, the occasional client will choose to replace synthetic stones with something natural. While the antique vintage value may be compromised, a happy client is a return client.

Patek Philippe annual calendar and moohphase wristwatch in 18-karat white gold

Diamond and platinum plaque pendant set with calibre-cut synthetic sapphires, circa 1920.

Cartier 'Bagnoire' in 18-karat yellow gold

Platinum, diamond, and sapphire brooch circa 1910. The center stone is a real sapphire, while the calibre-cut accents are synthetic pphires.



Evidential circumstances
Progressive shifts in technology between the two world wars occurred due to sweeping alterations during and following the post-industrial ‘machine age.’ Methods and inventions like the assembly line, and tool and die machines constructed with their precisely calculated calibration, were changing the scope of manufacturing; everything new–from the airplane to the zipper–was hailed as revolutionary in terms of increased industrial production and profit. Anything man-made was glorified. It’s into these circumstances that synthetic gemstones were born as an acceptable choice for decorating high-quality rings, brooches, bracelets, etc. If natural stones were a good choice, then man-made were ever better and more enticing.

Synthetic stones were marketed to the jewellery-buying public as a specific selling feature that could often cost more than their natural counterparts, since they were considered more rare and uncommon due to having being engineered in a laboratory. Newfangled innovations were embraced as part of the grand, modern future.

You’re most likely to see items from the Art Deco period featuring main stones in old European, Asscher, emerald, pear, shield, or triangle cuts, enhanced by coloured thin lines of caliber or baguette cuts forming geometric linear angles. Channel settings of synthetic rubies, sapphires, or emeralds contrast with diamonds in wide filigree strap bracelets, plaque pendants, and wristwatches. Less common is a “Toi et Moi” style ring, set with a pear-shaped diamond and a synthetic blue spinel.

Contemporary usage
Sometimes, the setting is the dominant factor in a design. Consider a ring containing two CZs and a synthetic blue sapphire set within a hefty chunk of platinum. In this case, the metal’s substantial weight–all 84 g of it–was more important to the designer than the gems. Watchmakers utilized colourless synthetic corundum for watch crystals for its superior scratch–resistant qualities and clarity.
So synthetic doesn’t mean second-class or less worthy when it comes to estate jewellery values. In fact, it is perfectly acceptable and not considered by professionals to be inferior in any way. Actually, their presence in a piece can hint at the authenticity to the period, thereby adding to the credibility regarding the circa dating.

Conventionally accepted meanings can be misunderstood when used out of context. Don’t be held back by terminology. Instead, embrace these innovations from the past in your future sales. Developing this appreciation gives Mother Nature a break and after all, she’s under enough pressure as it is these days.

More Articles

Pearls: The evolution of a classic
Alloys through the ages
Time and tide: Men’s jewellery through the ages
Understated beauty: Diving into mid-century modern design
Being cute: Whimsical jewellery captivates and charms
Leaf motifs: Perennially popular and always in vogue
SHE SAID YES - Now say yes to the jewels
Jadeite Jade
Culture of the supernatural
Timing is everything
Silver Linings
Industrial Chic
Put some thought into it
Romancing the stones
Orange you happy?
Cocktails anyone?
World events shape design
And the bead goes on
The state of estate sales
An endearing and enduring motif
Production evolves as it revolves
Wearable Art
Neither faux nor faux pas
World of Watches
Queen for a day
Future Connections
Function follows form
Convertible Creations
Gemstones A kaleidoscope of choice
Gifting: the vintage advantage
An eye for detail
Evolution in White
For the boys
A case for the watch
Vintage value
Gold: A standard of adornment
Portrait of an auction
Platinum period
Demistifying auction values
A magnificent tiara
Appraising the appraisal process for period jewels
The story of the Asscher cut
The Timeless Elegance of Art Deco
If jewels could talk... What stories they'd tell!
Solving the puzzle of period pieces
The jewellery of 1918 to 1939
The Magnificence of Micromosaics
Jersey Jewellery
Love, Victorian style
Fabergé: Jeweller to the Czars
Untouched jewels retain their value
'50s design full of optimism, exuberance
Cameo Appearance
Diamond aristocrats: a history of cut
Cufflinks with the Past
Estate jewellery as a source of rare and fine gems
The beauty of authentic Deco